The Lost Valentine

Jennifer Love Hewitt

Susan Allison

Betty White

Caroline Thomas

Sean Faris

Lucas Thomas

Billy Magnussen

Neil Thomas

Meghann Fahy

Young Caroline

Nadia Dajani

Julie Oliver

Lori Beth Sikes

Jenny (as Lori Beth Edgeman)

Gil Gerard

Neil Thomas Jr

Mike Pniewski

Craig Warren

Helmar Augustus Cooper

Joseph Williams

Ron Clinton Smith

Western Union Delivery Man

Tom Nowicki

Glenn Billings