Most Likely to Murder

Adam Pally

Billy

Rachel Bloom

Kara

Vincent Kartheiser

Lowell

John Reynolds

Perkins

Didi Conn

Billy's Mom

Ethan Phillips

Billy's Dad

Doug Mand

Duane

Hasan Minhaj

Amir

Rebecca Naomi Jones

Elana

Julia Goldani Telles

Tammy

Don Fanelli

Officer Matarazzo

Billy Eichner

Speigel